Probation Management Made Simple Nectar HR UKProbation periods are about to matter more than ever: are your managers actually managing them?

For many managers, probation works something like this:

  • Someone joins.
  • Their six-month probation date goes into the diary.
  • Everyone gets busy.
  • A few little concerns crop up along the way, but nobody really addresses them.
  • Then suddenly the probation review is next week, and somebody says: “I’m not sure they’re working out.”

 

From January 2027, leaving those conversations until the end of probation could become much riskier.

 

What’s changing?

From 1 January 2027, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal protection will reduce to six months.

 

For employers operating six-month probation periods, that creates an obvious challenge.  If the first meaningful conversation about an employee’s performance happens at their six-month probation review, the employer may already have reached the point at which the employee has acquired ordinary unfair dismissal protection.

 

That’s why the change isn’t simply something for HR to know about.  It’s a reason to look properly at how probation is being managed within your business.

 

A probation period isn’t a six-month waiting room.  Probation should give both the employer and the employee an opportunity to decide whether the role is working.

 

That means managers need to actively manage it.

 

Employees should understand:

  • what is expected of them
  • what good performance looks like
  • whether they are meeting those expectations
  • where improvement is needed
  • what support is available
  • what could happen if the required standard isn’t reached

 

If concerns exist at month two but nobody mentions them until month six, that’s not particularly helpful to anyone.  The employee hasn’t had a fair opportunity to understand the problem and improve.  The manager has spent several months hoping the issue will resolve itself.  And HR is then asked to deal with something that could have been addressed much earlier.

 

Don’t save everything up for the probation review

One of the biggest mistakes we see is treating the final probation review as the probation process.  It isn’t.  It should be the conclusion of a process that’s been happening throughout the employee’s first few months.

 

For a six-month probation period, employers could consider structured check-ins around:

  • Month one: Is the employee settling into the role? Are expectations clear? Is any additional training or support needed?
  • Month three: Is the employee meeting the expected standards? Are there any performance, conduct or attendance concerns that need addressing?
  • Month five: Is the employee on track to successfully complete probation? If there are outstanding concerns, have these been clearly communicated and documented?
  • Before month six: Make an appropriate decision and follow the relevant process. Don’t automatically wait for the six-month anniversary because that’s what the calendar invitation says.

 

The exact approach will depend on your organisation and your contractual arrangements, but the principle is simple:  Manage probation throughout probation.

 

Managers need to have the uncomfortable conversations

Often the problem isn’t the probation policy.  It’s that managers don’t want to have the conversation.  They notice someone is struggling but decide to give them a little longer.

 

They correct the employee’s work themselves rather than explaining what’s wrong.  They mention concerns informally but don’t make it clear that improvement is required.

 

Or they say nothing because they’re worried about knocking someone’s confidence.  Usually, this is done with good intentions.  But avoiding the conversation rarely helps the employee.

 

Good probation management doesn’t mean looking for reasons to dismiss someone. It means giving people clear expectations, honest feedback and a genuine opportunity to succeed.

If something isn’t going well, kind and clear beats silent and hopeful.

 

Documentation matters too

You don’t need to create a 20-page evidence pack every time somebody is five minutes late.  But managers should keep appropriate records of probation conversations.

 

If performance concerns have been discussed, record:

  • what the concern was
  • what standard was expected
  • what the employee said
  • what support or training was agreed
  • what improvement was required
  • when progress would be reviewed

 

Follow-up emails or probation review records can help create a clear picture of what’s happened throughout the probation period.  That becomes particularly important if difficult decisions need to be made later.

 

Six months doesn’t mean employers can dismiss freely before then

This is an important one.  A shorter qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal doesn’t create a six-month window in which employers can simply dismiss someone without considering why.

 

There are employment protections that don’t depend on having six months’ service.  For example, issues involving discrimination, whistleblowing and certain automatically unfair reasons for dismissal can create risk regardless of how long somebody has worked for you.

So, “they’re still in probation” is not, by itself, a reason to skip a proper HR conversation.

 

Where there’s any uncertainty about the reason for dismissal or the appropriate process, take advice before acting.

 

What should employers do now?

January isn’t far away, so now is a sensible time to look at your probation processes.

  • Review your probation periods

If you currently operate a six-month probation period, consider how the January changes interact with your existing process.

Don’t assume that shortening probation is automatically the answer. The important thing is ensuring decisions and conversations happen at the right time.

  • Check your contracts and probation policy

Make sure contractual wording, your probation procedure and what managers do in practice line up.

Pay particular attention to notice provisions, extending probation and who has authority to confirm, extend or end probation.

  • Introduce earlier review points

Don’t rely on one meeting at the end.

Simple scheduled check-ins throughout probation can identify issues much earlier.

  • Give managers reminders

If HR holds the probation dates, don’t send the manager their first reminder a week before the deadline.

Build in prompts early enough for the manager to actually do something.

  • Train managers to give feedback

Managers don’t need to become employment lawyers.

They do need to know how to set expectations, address concerns, document conversations and ask for HR support when something isn’t going to plan.

  • Audit your current probation cases

Before January, look at employees who will reach six months’ service around the change.

Are there any outstanding concerns?

Have managers held the appropriate conversations?

Is documentation up to date?

Does anything need dealing with now rather than in a few months’ time?

 

 

Good probation management shouldn’t start because the law is changing  Really, none of this should be new.

A well-managed probation period has always been good people management.  The change in unfair dismissal protection simply makes it even more important that employers aren’t relying on a diary reminder and a last-minute meeting to manage somebody’s first six months.

Probation should be a period of regular communication, support and honest feedback.

 

And if the role isn’t working out?  That shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone at the final review.

The probation review should confirm the conversation you’ve been having for months, not start it.

 

Is your probation process ready for 2027?

If your probation process currently relies on managers remembering dates, having difficult conversations at the last minute or calling HR when the six-month deadline is already looming, now is a good time to review it.

 

Nectar HR can help you review your contracts, probation processes and manager guidance ahead of the January changes, helping you build a process that’s practical, consistent and works in the real world.

 

Good probation management isn’t about making it easier to dismiss people. It’s about giving employers and employees the best possible chance of getting things right from the start.